Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Brighton v Mansfield - Player Ratings
- Thread starter Trigger
- Start date
bright1064
New member
Kuipers 7
El-Abd 6
Elphick 5
Butters 4 (Rents 4)
Lynch 3
Robinson 4 (Elder 7)
Reid 5
Fraser 2 (Loft 2)
Cox 5
Revell 4
Forster 6
El-Abd 6
Elphick 5
Butters 4 (Rents 4)
Lynch 3
Robinson 4 (Elder 7)
Reid 5
Fraser 2 (Loft 2)
Cox 5
Revell 4
Forster 6
Mustela Furo
Advantage Player
- Jul 7, 2003
- 1,481
Robinson suffered a fractured metatarsal midway through the first half, and played on until the 79th minute ... so some consideration should be given there surely?
Barrel of Fun
Abort, retry, fail
Kuipers 5
El-Abd 7 MoM
Elphick 4
Butters 5 (Rents 3)
Lynch 3
Robinson 5 (Elder 7)
Reid 5
Fraser 3 (Loft 3)
Cox 5
Revell 4
Forster 5
El-Abd 7 MoM
Elphick 4
Butters 5 (Rents 3)
Lynch 3
Robinson 5 (Elder 7)
Reid 5
Fraser 3 (Loft 3)
Cox 5
Revell 4
Forster 5
Scotty Mac
New member
- Jul 13, 2003
- 24,405
kuipers - 5. decent stops, could have done better with the first
el-abd - 5. poor sod. every week he seems to play in a different position
elphick - 4. didnt look as good alongside butters due to the fact he was the sweeping defender
butters - 3. too slow now
lynch - 2. awful. most over rated player in brighton history?
robinson - 3. completely ineffective. IF he was injured, why the hell did he continue playing?
reid - 4. half the player he was on tuesday
fraser - 3. did he play a forward pass?
cox - 5. got down the line, but still loses vital seconds by cutting inside
revell - 3. got a goal, did nothing else. gave away possesion too cheaply
forster - 3. long balls forward do nothing for him
el-abd - 5. poor sod. every week he seems to play in a different position
elphick - 4. didnt look as good alongside butters due to the fact he was the sweeping defender
butters - 3. too slow now
lynch - 2. awful. most over rated player in brighton history?
robinson - 3. completely ineffective. IF he was injured, why the hell did he continue playing?
reid - 4. half the player he was on tuesday
fraser - 3. did he play a forward pass?
cox - 5. got down the line, but still loses vital seconds by cutting inside
revell - 3. got a goal, did nothing else. gave away possesion too cheaply
forster - 3. long balls forward do nothing for him
dougdeep
New member
Kuipers-7
ElAbd---5
Elphick-5
Butters-6
Lynch---4
Jake-----5
Reid-----5
Fraser---4
Cox------5
Forster--5
Revell----7
ElAbd---5
Elphick-5
Butters-6
Lynch---4
Jake-----5
Reid-----5
Fraser---4
Cox------5
Forster--5
Revell----7
Scotty Mac
New member
- Jul 13, 2003
- 24,405
possibly - but it begs the question why the hell wasnt he taken off?
Kuipers 6 - some good saves, neither good nor bad. Some early throws to left wing were hard to explain.
El-Abd 6 - really played well considering. Positionally sound and few of his usual howlers.
Elphick 4 - learning but in a team playing badly yesterday, he went AWOL
Butters 5 - strong in the air, but poor when they got behind us. Could have given Lynch more encouragement after two howlers.
(Rents 3) - really poor.
Lynch 2 - absolute mare. Sad sight though was seeing him soak up the crap he must have been getting with no obvious support from his team mates.
Robinson 4 - invisible, knocked off the ball too easily, watches as a Div 2 midfield bossed the game.
(Elder 6) - promising and one or two good efforts in the box. But no end product.
Reid 5 - needs a hard man to be at his best. tried to put his foot on the ball, but too often facing away from the oppo goal.
Fraser 4 - his worst game for ages.
(Loft 3) - poor
Cox 5 - did OK in fact, esp considering his broken foot. But their right back knew he was going to cut inside each time. No left foot makes him predictable.
Revell 6 - won quite a few headers but no midfield support. Scored a good goal. has more pace and control than Bas - think he did alright.
Forster 6 - can't do it all by himself. Resorted to long range shots in the end. Was clearly frustrated from the start (very odd rant at Fraser in the warm up). But liked the way the effort of the team increased when he got the arm band.
Deano 5 - should have known how to deal with Mansfield no matter how badly players were doing, but threadbare cupboard was there for all to see.
Crowd 3 - should be ashamed of themselves. Worst I can remember at Withdean.
El-Abd 6 - really played well considering. Positionally sound and few of his usual howlers.
Elphick 4 - learning but in a team playing badly yesterday, he went AWOL
Butters 5 - strong in the air, but poor when they got behind us. Could have given Lynch more encouragement after two howlers.
(Rents 3) - really poor.
Lynch 2 - absolute mare. Sad sight though was seeing him soak up the crap he must have been getting with no obvious support from his team mates.
Robinson 4 - invisible, knocked off the ball too easily, watches as a Div 2 midfield bossed the game.
(Elder 6) - promising and one or two good efforts in the box. But no end product.
Reid 5 - needs a hard man to be at his best. tried to put his foot on the ball, but too often facing away from the oppo goal.
Fraser 4 - his worst game for ages.
(Loft 3) - poor
Cox 5 - did OK in fact, esp considering his broken foot. But their right back knew he was going to cut inside each time. No left foot makes him predictable.
Revell 6 - won quite a few headers but no midfield support. Scored a good goal. has more pace and control than Bas - think he did alright.
Forster 6 - can't do it all by himself. Resorted to long range shots in the end. Was clearly frustrated from the start (very odd rant at Fraser in the warm up). But liked the way the effort of the team increased when he got the arm band.
Deano 5 - should have known how to deal with Mansfield no matter how badly players were doing, but threadbare cupboard was there for all to see.
Crowd 3 - should be ashamed of themselves. Worst I can remember at Withdean.
Mustela Furo
Advantage Player
- Jul 7, 2003
- 1,481
Coz until he had the x-ray last night they didn't know.
Suspect that Robinson played on through the pain and didn't make a song and dance about it.
Uncle C
Well-known member
Cox 5 - did OK in fact, esp considering his broken foot. But their right back knew he was going to cut inside each time. No left foot makes him predictable.
Robinson suffered a fractured metatarsal midway through the first half, and played on until the 79th minute ... so some consideration should be given there surely?
Just how many injuries did we pick up?
Robinson suffered a fractured metatarsal midway through the first half, and played on until the 79th minute ... so some consideration should be given there surely?
Just how many injuries did we pick up?
Albion Edd
Brighton til die
Kuipers 6
El Abd 6
Elphick 4
Butters 3
Lynch 2
Robinson 5
Reid 4
Fraser 3
Cox 5
Forster 5
Revell 4
Elder 6
Loft 5
Rents 4
El Abd 6
Elphick 4
Butters 3
Lynch 2
Robinson 5
Reid 4
Fraser 3
Cox 5
Forster 5
Revell 4
Elder 6
Loft 5
Rents 4
Joey Jo Jo Jr. Shabadoo
Waxing chumps like candles since ‘75
- Oct 4, 2003
- 11,127
Kuipers 6 Kept us in it with a couple of decent saves when you'd have thought they would score.
El-Abd 6 Should have done better when he burst into the area in the first half and actually had a shot. The only one of the back four not to look like a total arse.
Elphick 5 Gave the ball away too easily and was poor in the air
Butters 4 Slow, clearly carrying an injury from early on, but as captain needs to encourage players more so their heads don't drop.
Lynch 3 Poor at left back, clearly hadn't recovered from the virus he had, looked better when he moved to centre back for the second half.
Robinson 3 Poor for most of the game, he should have been more honest about the injury if it was affecting his performance and told the bench he needed to come off.
Reid 4 Needed a better partner in midfield, struggled to create anything.
Fraser 3 Don't think I've seen him look as poor as he did yesterday, the only time he got stuck in he won the free kick that lead to our goal, this didn't encourage him like it should have done though. Maybe like Lynch he hasn't recovered from the virus.
Cox 5 Good delivery for the free kick but is wasted on the left as he needs to cut inside and get the ball on his right foot too often.
Revell 5 Took his goal well but didn't have a first touch when needed.
Forster 6 Vocal and supportive of other team mates when he got the arm band but we need to play to his strengths more.
Subs
Rents 4 Gave the ball away to cheaply when playing left back, should have switched with Cox and played left midfield when we went 3 at the back.
Loft 3 Did he really touch the ball, lacking his normal energy it seems.
Elder 5 Seemed to be up for it when he came on and lifted the team into actually trying something, forced a good save out of their keeper with a good header.
El-Abd 6 Should have done better when he burst into the area in the first half and actually had a shot. The only one of the back four not to look like a total arse.
Elphick 5 Gave the ball away too easily and was poor in the air
Butters 4 Slow, clearly carrying an injury from early on, but as captain needs to encourage players more so their heads don't drop.
Lynch 3 Poor at left back, clearly hadn't recovered from the virus he had, looked better when he moved to centre back for the second half.
Robinson 3 Poor for most of the game, he should have been more honest about the injury if it was affecting his performance and told the bench he needed to come off.
Reid 4 Needed a better partner in midfield, struggled to create anything.
Fraser 3 Don't think I've seen him look as poor as he did yesterday, the only time he got stuck in he won the free kick that lead to our goal, this didn't encourage him like it should have done though. Maybe like Lynch he hasn't recovered from the virus.
Cox 5 Good delivery for the free kick but is wasted on the left as he needs to cut inside and get the ball on his right foot too often.
Revell 5 Took his goal well but didn't have a first touch when needed.
Forster 6 Vocal and supportive of other team mates when he got the arm band but we need to play to his strengths more.
Subs
Rents 4 Gave the ball away to cheaply when playing left back, should have switched with Cox and played left midfield when we went 3 at the back.
Loft 3 Did he really touch the ball, lacking his normal energy it seems.
Elder 5 Seemed to be up for it when he came on and lifted the team into actually trying something, forced a good save out of their keeper with a good header.
Stevie Boy
Well-known member
kuipers - 7. Two great saves, couldnt do much with the goals
el-abd - 6. no mistakes this week
elphick - 3. didnt look solid at all
butters - 3. won every header but was slow today
lynch - -5. absolute disgrace, not worthy in wearing the stripes, so OVER RATED
robinson - 3. utter gash
reid - 4. very poor for his standards
fraser - -4. f***ing usless, again not worthy in wearing the stripes
cox - 2. ran down the line, and passed to their players everytime, cant use his left foot so why stick him on the left
revell - 3. scored, but thats it,
forster - 4. long balls werent any good for him, did run his heart out though
Elder - 7. Should have scored, but a greart save
Loft - 2. Ran arou nd like a headless chicken
Rents - 3. did nothing to remember
Wilkins -10 Why sit in the stands?? u cant manange a team from there, wrong tactics, long ball everytime. not the man for the job, i have never wanted him as manager, get him out before he takes us DOWN.
Mansfield Players - 8. Showed the albion how to pass and play the ball on the ground.
Mansfield Supporters - 10 Great Noise thoughtout, Well Done
What happened to our midfield, were they still on the training ground yesterday??
el-abd - 6. no mistakes this week
elphick - 3. didnt look solid at all
butters - 3. won every header but was slow today
lynch - -5. absolute disgrace, not worthy in wearing the stripes, so OVER RATED
robinson - 3. utter gash
reid - 4. very poor for his standards
fraser - -4. f***ing usless, again not worthy in wearing the stripes
cox - 2. ran down the line, and passed to their players everytime, cant use his left foot so why stick him on the left
revell - 3. scored, but thats it,
forster - 4. long balls werent any good for him, did run his heart out though
Elder - 7. Should have scored, but a greart save
Loft - 2. Ran arou nd like a headless chicken
Rents - 3. did nothing to remember
Wilkins -10 Why sit in the stands?? u cant manange a team from there, wrong tactics, long ball everytime. not the man for the job, i have never wanted him as manager, get him out before he takes us DOWN.
Mansfield Players - 8. Showed the albion how to pass and play the ball on the ground.
Mansfield Supporters - 10 Great Noise thoughtout, Well Done
What happened to our midfield, were they still on the training ground yesterday??
The bench knew he was in pain because he was pouring cold water over his foot during a break in the game (I think when El Abd was getting treatment) I commented on it at the time wondering if he was injured.
kuipers - 7. Two great saves, couldnt do much with the goals
el-abd - 6. no mistakes this week
elphick - 3. didnt look solid at all
butters - 3. won every header but was slow today
lynch - -5. absolute disgrace, not worthy in wearing the stripes, so OVER RATED
robinson - 3. utter gash
reid - 4. very poor for his standards
fraser - -4. f***ing usless, again not worthy in wearing the stripes
cox - 2. ran down the line, and passed to their players everytime, cant use his left foot so why stick him on the left
revell - 3. scored, but thats it,
forster - 4. long balls werent any good for him, did run his heart out though
Elder - 7. Should have scored, but a greart save
Loft - 2. Ran arou nd like a headless chicken
Rents - 3. did nothing to remember
Wilkins -10 Why sit in the stands?? u cant manange a team from there, wrong tactics, long ball everytime. not the man for the job, i have never wanted him as manager, get him out before he takes us DOWN.
Mansfield Players - 8. Showed the albion how to pass and play the ball on the ground.
Mansfield Supporters - 10 Great Noise thoughtout, Well Done
What happened to our midfield, were they still on the training ground yesterday??
what a stupid post..........wilkins out he is the man for the job he is trying to manage of players that think they are beter than what they are.......
Withdean Wanderer
Banned
Kuipers - 7 - some good stops
El-abd - 6 - not a bad backpass in sight
Elphick - 5 - gradually got better
Butters - 5 - looking a bit too slow now, but good in the air
Lynch - 2 - oh dear
Robinson - 2 - didn't make any impact at all
Fraser - 3 - cannot play a forward pass at all
Reid - 2 - shocking, quite a contrast from the other day
Cox - 5 - our brightest thing going forward, but so many crosses to nobody and his passing was poor. No left foot - should have gone over to right wing
Revell - 4 - one goal, bugger all else. Although that's admittedly more than the rest of them!
Forster - 3 - dreadful
Elder - 5 - came on and tried
Loft - 3 - looked scared to be out there
Rents - 3 - not his fault, but Right wing? A comical wilkins decision
El-abd - 6 - not a bad backpass in sight
Elphick - 5 - gradually got better
Butters - 5 - looking a bit too slow now, but good in the air
Lynch - 2 - oh dear
Robinson - 2 - didn't make any impact at all
Fraser - 3 - cannot play a forward pass at all
Reid - 2 - shocking, quite a contrast from the other day
Cox - 5 - our brightest thing going forward, but so many crosses to nobody and his passing was poor. No left foot - should have gone over to right wing
Revell - 4 - one goal, bugger all else. Although that's admittedly more than the rest of them!
Forster - 3 - dreadful
Elder - 5 - came on and tried
Loft - 3 - looked scared to be out there
Rents - 3 - not his fault, but Right wing? A comical wilkins decision